Have you ever fumbled with your keys in the pouring rain, only to discover you’ve been locked out of your house? It’s a scenario that can leave anyone feeling frustrated and vulnerable. But fear not! If you find yourself locked out of the house, a locksmith from Okey Locksmith can quickly get you back inside with minimal hassle.
However, after our prompt and professional service gets you back inside, a question might linger: what to do with the locks themselves? Should you rekey locks or replace them entirely? This blog delves into the key differences (pun intended!) between rekeying and replacing locks, including the cost-effectiveness and process of lock rekeying, empowering you to make the best choice for your specific situation.
Understanding the Fundamentals: Lock Rekeying vs. Lock Replacement

When it comes to securing your home, the decision between lock rekeying and replacement can be crucial. Understanding the nuances of each option, including rekeying locks as an affordable and quick solution for improving home security, can help you make the best choice for your specific needs.
Rekeying
This process involves rearranging the internal pins of your existing lock. Think of it as giving your current lock a brand new security code! By manipulating these pins, a locksmith renders old keys inoperable and creates a new set that functions smoothly. Rekeying is a cost-effective solution when the existing hardware, including the door lock cylinder and internal mechanism, is in good working order. Additionally, rekeying allows multiple locks to be operated with the same key.
Replacement
Here, the entire lockset, encompassing the cylinder, internal mechanism, and sometimes even the exterior housing, is removed and replaced with a completely new lock unit. This is ideal when your locks are:
- Old and Worn-Out: Over time, locks can become stiff, malfunction, or develop security vulnerabilities. Replacing them with a new, high-security lockset bolsters your home’s overall protection.
- Subpar Security: Older lock models might not offer the level of security you desire. Replacing them with modern deadbolts with stronger cores and advanced features like bump-proof mechanisms provides significant peace of mind.
When it Makes Sense to Rekey Locks
Rekeying locks is the safest choice in several scenarios:
Lost or Stolen Keys
If you’ve misplaced your house keys or suspect someone might have a copy, rekeying ensures unauthorized access is blocked. This is a much more cost-effective solution compared to replacing all the locks, especially if you have multiple doors in your home. Rekeying the same lock ensures that old keys no longer work.
Moving into a New Home
You never know how many copies of the old keys are floating around. Rekeying provides peace of mind, especially for new homeowners, by ensuring only authorized individuals have access. Rekeying locks of the same brand ensures compatibility and ease of use.
Multiple Users, One Same Key
Do you have roommates, frequently hire home service providers like dog walkers or house cleaners, or share your vacation home with family? Rekeying allows you to create a master key system. This lets you designate one key that unlocks all the doors, while others only access specific areas, like bedrooms or garages. This offers a convenient way to manage access control without the hassle of carrying around multiple keys. Additionally, keypad locks offer a convenient solution for multiple users without the need for physical keys.
Cost-Effectiveness
Rekeying is significantly cheaper than replacing your entire lockset. It’s a quick and simple process, perfect for situations where the existing locks are functional and in good condition.
Knowing When Replacement is the Better Option
While rekeying offers numerous benefits, it is often better to replace locks when:
Worn-Out Lock Cylinder
As mentioned earlier, worn-out locks can become unreliable and pose security risks. Replacing them with a new, high-security deadbolt lock is a wise investment in your home’s safety and peace of mind.
Security Upgrade
Do you want to enhance your home security? Modern deadbolt locks with stronger cores and advanced features like anti-picking mechanisms and drill resistance offer additional protection. Replacing your old locks with smart locks, such as a keypad lock or fingerprint scanner, provides even greater convenience and control, allowing you to grant or restrict access remotely.
How much does it cost to rekey a lock vs. replace it?
Rekeying is generally significantly cheaper than replacing a lock. The exact cost depends on the number of locks you need rekeyed and the complexity of the locks themselves. However, it’s usually a fraction of the price of replacing the entire lockset.
Can you rekey your own locks?
While it’s technically possible to rekey some locks yourself with a rekey kit and some DIY know-how, it’s not recommended for most homeowners. Rekeying requires specific tools and expertise to ensure the job is done correctly. An improperly rekeyed lock can be more vulnerable to picking or manipulation. For optimal security and peace of mind, it’s best to leave this task to a professional locksmith like Okey Locksmith.
Will rekeying work with all types of locks?
Rekeying locks can be done on most residential door locks, including deadbolts, doorknobs with keypads, and even some electronic locks. However, there may be some older or higher-security locks that cannot be rekeyed. A locksmith from Okey Locksmith can assess your specific locks and advise you on the best course of action.
Okey Locksmith: Your Trusted Partner in Home Security
Whether you need to rekey locks or replace them entirely with new models, Okey Locksmith is your one-stop shop! Our licensed and insured professionals have the experience and expertise to handle all your lock-related needs. We offer a wide range of services, including:
- Rekeying all locks in your home, including deadbolts, doorknobs with keypads, and electronic locks. Lock rekey services are a cost-effective alternative to changing locks, allowing you to maintain your existing hardware while enhancing security.
- Replacing existing hardware with new locks of various brands and security levels, ensuring compatibility with your existing door type and thickness.
- Creating a master key system for a streamlined access management solution.
- Providing expert advice on the best lock solutions for your specific needs and budget.
We understand that lockouts can be stressful, and we’re here to help 24/7. Our emergency service guarantees a fast and efficient response to get you back inside quickly.
Call Okey Locksmith today! Don’t wait until you’re locked out to address your security needs!